We're talking about console games here and not third rate games from 10 years ago.
Halo 3's customization is far more in depth than anything out their and like I said before. The award is for innovation and Portal doesn't deserve the award just for introducing ONE new weapon that you can only use by your lonely self.

Halo's come a long way since the first one and with each new game that came out was something new and better. This is why Halo 3 is typically the top played Xbox 360 game each week.

This isn't that big of a deal. This is mainly done because of the new update that will allow you to download your 360 games to the HDD, but you still need the disk in the tray to play it. (For obvious reasons XD )

HA HA, toadwarrior thinks that Portal should have won. Aha ha, that's really funny. The only thing INNOVATIVE about Portal is the portal gun and that's it. They definitely don't deserve the award for making level one the same as level 20. The level concepts are all the same and their isn't anything more to it. It's like playing Mario Bros--keep doing the same thing by yourself.