The major problem underlying this review isn't the score at all: It's the fact that the reviewer dislikes linnear games.He disliked Square.Enix changing what he thinks a Final Fantasy should be and then he writtes the review based on his personal taste.

I hate walking arround and talking to useless NPC's, or walking trough a city to buy a bottle in a shop so I can get the ilusion that its a true world.But it's my personal opinion, It doesn't mean that if I play or see a sandbox game focused on freedom or choices I couldn't state that it's a masterpiece.The point is being fair with the game and readers and let aside personal tastes.

I agree with you, Mooks.The magic is lost.Read my comment if u wish.

Bought it two days ago and and I've played both campaign and multiplayer.
Modern Warfare is a shinning game.It was awesome to me because of the spectacular situations the plot deserved, following the sniper through Prypiat and feeling like a rookie, dying on a nuclear blast, going trough a ship killing sleeping people...all mixed with fantastic graphics and gameplay.THE MAJOR SUCCESS WAS THE SCRIPT.

That's why I'm dissapointed with with MW2.Better graphics?sure.But the scripts doesnt give you the moments offered in MW.Something is lost: they've changed the rithym, now every action moments are very fast and everything is more chaotic.I had the feeling that I didnt control the game, the game was controlling me, and inmersion is lost.

A major mistake is the blood when someone hurts you.Am I the only one getting confused by them?? it's so frustrating...

Special ops is the only part of the game that remind me to the greatness of MW.

Dissapointing.I had high expectations, I can enjoy it, but it's a 7-8 game and Uncharted is waaaay better in epicness terms.

I'm used to ask for coherence in a reviewer when analizing a game.
Today I feel like I get to ask coherence in gamers. Some of the comments are really hard with Uncharted 2 because it's too linear. Trying to figure what kind of games this people would like I can imagine GTA,Zelda,Super mario 64...and many more. That's O.K to me, no problem at all, but if you don't like any of those it means that you are not honest.
If you disliked Uncharted 2 because of linear, you got to love all the opposite: games showing the so called freedom.
Maybe you like horror movies and you dislike comedy and it can be understood, but you can always say: 'I don't like comedies but this one is a masterpiece even if I dislike comedy'.

I don't like fihting games, but Street fighter IV is a masterpiece, as simple as that.And then I give honest reasons analizing sound,visuals and all the stuff besides my personal tastes.

ZAKROCZ you disliked Uncharted 2 and you compare it with the visuals of killzone 2 and a few lines later you talk about Demon's souls.For Christsake,what has those two games in common to be compared with Uncharted 2?.It's like comparing The full metal jacket with toy story 2.It doesnt make any sense.Maybe you should know yourself better or one day you will find yourself buying a ticket to see a comedy, not an action film
Be honest and say it loud : "I don't like platformers, never will, and I prefer pure hardcore action games,but Uncharted 2 is a masterpiece."

Mefistófeles dixit.

Maybe my internet line doesn´t work too well, I can´t check where in the te rank are Metal gear solid 4,Wipeout, killzone2 and Mas Effect.

I bought space Giraffe, played for a while and erased it.It stinks, pure garbage.

Be serious.