"Gears of War was a new IP and all the 360 suckers bought tha borken piece of garbage"

It's a bit of the overstatement mate. GOW is a superb fun game for me.

Well, their engine is amazing.
Nothing will stop bad developers in achieving their goal I'm afraid. :)

A matter of preference. :)
I see your point but I still like those thing from time too time. Fro me it's more genre dependable.
In MGS4 you're always want too be there, while in fable2 you're challenged to imagine and dream. :)

"I registered for this website to rant about the stupidity and utter lack of any sensible knowledge that was applied in making this list."

You shouldn't have done so, cause yours is definitely not mind blowing either.

And DForce is back to HIS usual spot. 8D