True but shooters none the less. One being a supposedly triple A title while the other is simply not. I'm just saying that WaW offers one of the best online experiences (IMO) on a console to date. As for the rest of the game... it's still the same stuff we've been playing since CoD1 so to me it's not suprising Edge only gave it a 6.

Why? Because it's (essentially) still the same game we've been playing all those years ago? Don't get me wrong, I had tons of fun with the Beta and just ordered a used copy but it's not anything we haven't seen before.

The singleplayer will be so-so for me and I'll probably play it once but the multiplayer is where it's at for me. Definitely one of the best streamlined online experiences to date and when compared to a so-called AAA+ game like Gears 2, WaW leaves gears' online portion in dust.